Favicon Advertisements Could Work

Favicons

I came across an article the other day from Young Go Getter that I found interesting. Favicon advertising seems to be gaining in popularity with the design showcase niche sites, but I like the idea and think it may be a good idea for any site. Of course, as with anything, there is an upside, as well as a downside. You just have to decide what is best for your site.

The Upside

1. Very Small

A favicon is small, so it would be very non-invasive to your readers to display them. That’s one of the main issues I have with other forms of advertisements such as adsense. On top of being somewhat unappealing visually, to generate any money at all, site owners try to blend them to make them look like links to internal sections of their site or they throw them right in the middle of the content which I hate.

The fact that they are small also has another benefit in that you can display more of them. Lets assume you want to display 20 at $10 a piece per month. That’s an extra $2400 per year. Not to shabby for such a small area of ads especially if that is on top of what you’re already making with other forms of monetization. It’s a nice addition.

2. Potential to Make More

The potential is there to make more money than other forms of private advertising. The usual trend is to display a 125x125 advertisement somewhere in the sidebar. Usually you’ll find anywhere from four to six of these advertisements on a site. If your selling them for $10 a piece as you were the favicon, you’re only making $480 per year. That’s a considerable difference. The 125x125 icons are great, but there is just no way you could possibly show 20 of them in your sidebar.

The Downside

1. Very Small

Didn’t you just say that was an upside? Well, yes I did, but read on. smile

The fact that they are so small could potentially make them more difficult to sell. Once you have a bunch lined up in a row, they all start running together, so it’s debatable whether or not you would actually be helping your advertisers by sending them traffic (that’s the whole point right?). It’s more luck of the draw on which icons get clicked.

2. A Lot to Sell

On top of icons seeming to run together, there is a lot more of them to sell than the normal four or six 125x125 ads (hey, you just said more was better because it could mean more money!). Yes, I did say that, but the fact that there are more is both good and bad. It’s good if your site gets a lot of exposure and actually has the ability to sell all of the spots. If your site is new and doesn’t receive a lot of traffic, you’re not likely to sell any of the spots, so having 20 or so empty favicon ad spots just sitting there on your site doesn’t give a good vibe to visitors.

What Do You Think?

I’ve thought about trying a small section of them here on Random Jabber. I figure it will not hurt anything to try and if it doesn’t work out, no harm done.

What do you think about the whole idea? Good or not so much?

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to the full RSS feed.

Comments

1Sam jabbered...

I like the idea. They’re very uncluttered, and they tend to pique my curiosity. I like them well enough that I tried to set up my blogroll using favicons. (That didn’t work so well.)

You know there’s a WordPress plugin for this, right? Run a search for AdIcons. Unfortunately, I haven’t found a TypePad equivalent.

Posted on Wed Oct 3, 2007

2Limitless jabbered...

Well, I think this kind of advertising is good if you know how to sell it, sometimes userds become “Blind” to this kind of ads ,) Good work!

Posted on Wed Oct 3, 2007

3Deron Sizemore jabbered...

Sam: Why didn’t the favicon blogroll work out for you?

Nope, didn’t realize there was a WordPress plugin for this type of thing. That’s kinda cool that they have something like that for WordPress. I’ve never used WordPress though. I’m not sure if ExpressionEngine has something like it or not. To my knowledge, no.

Limitless: Yes, selling it is a huge part of it. The problem with any type of ad is that eventually if not almost instantly, users become blind to them. You really have to get creative sometimes.

Posted on Wed Oct 3, 2007

4Sam jabbered...

Deron, the blogroll notion didn’t work out so well because not all of the blogs I wanted to link to had favicons, which presented me with the problem of not linking to them (which wasn’t really an option), maintaining two separate blogrolls (one favicon and one text), or just abandoning the favicon option completely. I ended up doing the latter.

Sorry about the WP faux pas. I’ve gotten to the point that I assume I’m the only person NOT using WordPress. wink

Posted on Wed Oct 3, 2007

5Deron Sizemore jabbered...

Sam: No problem at all. Yeah, there are a few of us out there not using WordPress. They are few and far between it seems. smile

Makes sense with your blogroll. I forget sometimes that not everyone has a favicon.

Posted on Wed Oct 3, 2007

6Brian Purkiss jabbered...

I like the idea!
I’ve seen it over at DesignSnack.com - but never thought of using it on my blog!  In fact, there are entire web sites devoted to that!  (The Million Dollar Homepage)

At any rate.
I think it has great potential.  If the icons are done right - they could have almost as much impact as the larger icons!
Something else to consider is the pricing.  If you were to sell a 125x125 ad for $10 - then you might want to consider selling a favicon for $5.
That idea is used over at Wordpress Designer.com.  He has his main advertisements in the form of 125x125 ads.  But then he has ‘small potato advertisers’ that are text ads below that - and they’re cheaper.  (They used to be smaller icons - but it changed)

So.
I like the idea.
I think you should give it a try.
And I’ll probably end up trying it when I build a web site that someone would want to advertize on.

Posted on Fri Oct 5, 2007

7Wallace jabbered...

you can use the plugin http://www.rebitran.com/adicons-for-wordpress,
i think cssremix and designsnack used the same plugin.

Posted on Fri Oct 5, 2007

8Deron Sizemore jabbered...

Brian:Yeah I would like to try, but honestly I doubt anyone would want to advertise here either, so like you, once I build a site that someone wants to advertise one (maybe NiceStylesheet?) I might try it. smile

Wallace: Hey thanks for dropping by to comment. Glad to have you around. Thank you for the link, but I wouldn’t be able to use that plugin though as I’m not using WordPress. I’m a loyal ExpressionEngine user. smile

Posted on Fri Oct 5, 2007

9George jabbered...

interesting idea. I can see favicon ads works very well in mobile environment. 16x16 icon + 1 line of text link.

Posted on Tue Oct 9, 2007

10Deron Sizemore jabbered...

George: Yes, you may very well be right. I see the web making a shift to mobile devices in the coming years, so this type of advertising may really catch on since they are so small. Good idea.

Posted on Tue Oct 9, 2007

11Brian Purkiss jabbered...

I was over at DesignSnack.com and they’re actually doing this type of advertizing.
However…
When you hover over the icon, a small window pops up with a description of the link.

That is probably the key to that type of advertizing.
Hardly anyone will just click on a small icon.  But, if the small icon intregues the viewer, he/she will learn more by simply hovering over the icon.

Posted on Fri Oct 12, 2007

12Deron Sizemore jabbered...

Brian: I actually noticed that the other day also. That sort of pop up effect is pretty easily done with CSS and/or Javascript I believe. I think it’s definitely the way to go if you try this form of advertising.

Posted on Fri Oct 12, 2007

Comment on This Article

Please keep comments clean and on topic.


(Never Shared)


Remember me?

Notify me when someone responds?

Please verify that you are human and not an evil spamming robot.

Is fire hot or cold? (3 character(s) required)

Subscribe to Random Jabber

What is RSS?

Subscribe via email instead:

Nice Stylesheet - Fresh CSS Inspiration Advertise on Random Jabber

Topics

Comment Leaders